Want to share with your friends too?

India
27 Sep 2018

#AyodhyaVerdict: Case not to be referred to larger-bench, rules SC

Ayodhya-verdict: All you need to know

Giving a verdict which will have a direct impact on the decades-old dispute of Ram Mandir and Babri Masjid, the Supreme Court on Thursday ruled that the case related to mosque being integral for praying in Islam will not be referred to a larger bench.

About the 1994 judgment in Ismail Faruqui case, the bench noted the paragraph 52 needs to be understood in the context of land acquisition proceedings.

Here are the details.

In context

Ayodhya-verdict: All you need to know
In 1994, SC ruled mosque is not essential for praying

Looking back

In 1994, SC ruled mosque is not essential for praying

The bench was hearing plea which challenged the Union of India v/s Ismail Faruqui case verdict.

In 1994, the apex court ruled mosque wasn't "an essential part of the practice of the religion of Islam" hence "its acquisition (by the state) is not prohibited by the provisions in the Constitution of India."

Muslim bodies argued this 'sweeping' verdict should be revisited.

Details

Justice Bhushan says judgment shouldn't be read broadly

Justice Bhushan pronounced the majority judgment on his and CJI Misra's behalf.

"Observations in Ismail Faruqui judgment on mosques as not essential to religion is in the context of the acquisition of mosque and made with respect to the facts of that case," he said.

He added the previous judgment need not to be read broadly to mean mosque can never be essential to practice of Islam.

Love India news?

Stay updated with the latest happenings.

Notify Me

Present case will be judged independently

Justice Nazeer dissents with bench on verdict

In this verdict, Justice Nazeer was the sole dissenter. He said, "What is essential to religion as laid down in the 1994 case was arrived at without comprehensive examination. Questionable observations in Ismail Faruqui have permeated the Allahabad High Court verdict."

Ask NewsBytes
User Image

Next Timeline