India

Breaking myths about Aadhaar: What's true, what's not?

10 Apr 2017 | By Gogona Saikia
Breaking myths around Aadhaar

The Modi-government has gradually extended the scope of Aadhaar and made it mandatory for various social welfare schemes, to the criticism of many.

Many are unhappy with the move, which the Centre undertook despite a Supreme Court ruling prohibiting from making it mandatory.

Before criticizing it, however, one needs to know what Aadhaar exactly is, and what it's not. We break some myths here.

In context: Breaking myths around Aadhaar

10 Apr 2017Breaking myths about Aadhaar: What's true, what's not?

UniquenessMyth: Aadhaar is a 'unique' identity card

The Aadhaar is a number associated to an applicant. Unlike voter ID and PAN cards, it has no security features attached to it.

One can easily download and print multiple copies of the document, lessening the authenticity level of the document.

Yet, it is accepted at several places, including by airlines, as valid proof of identity.

Love India news?
Stay updated with the latest happenings.
Myth: Aadhaar is a proof of residence

ResidenceMyth: Aadhaar is a proof of residence

The address column in the Aadhaar application is optional; moreover, one does not need to furnish proof of residence, which means an applicant can provide any address since it won't be verified by the UIDAI (Unique Identification Authority of India) authorities anyway.

However, banks still ask for Aadhaar for the 'Know Your Customer' verification.

CitizenshipMyth: Aadhaar is a proof of citizenship

The Aadhaar (Targeted delivery of financial and other subsidies, benefits and services) Bill, 2016, states explicitly that "Aadhaar number (is) not evidence of citizenship or domicile, etc".

But, anyone who has lived in India for at least 182 days is eligible for Aadhaar.

And, the passport authority says Aadhaar will "expedite processing of passport applications"; the passport then becomes a valid proof of citizenship.

Myth: Identity theft can be eliminated using biometrics

Though Aadhaar's biometric techniques have been hailed as revolutionary, one needs to remember that such process have their drawbacks. Fingerprint scanning, for example, is inaccurate in about 5% cases worldwide, and 15% in India, where manual labour is widely prevalent.

PrivacyMyth: Aadhaar is a massive violation of privacy

Critics have slammed the Aadhaar as an invasion of privacy, alleging the government maintains a central database of citizens' details.

However, one needs to remember that the government already has access to such information through other documents, including passports, PAN cards, driving licences, voter IDs and more.

Details of Aadhaar account holders cannot legally be shared with third parties without their consent.

Love India news?
Stay updated with the latest happenings.

ExpensesMyth: Expenses incurred will be tremendous

Contrary to complaints of 'high cost' by many critics, the World Bank has reported that India is saving $1 billion annually by using Aadhaar, due to the reduced scope for corruption in public services.

Earlier, the National Institute of Public Finance and Policy found that integrating Aadhaar with social schemes like MNREGA, PDS and LPG subsidies would bring "substantial benefits".