No MCC violation by Modi and Rahul: EC

Politics

03 May 2019

Election Commission gives clean chits to both Modi and Rahul

Handing over a long rope to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the Election Commission gave him another clean chit on Thursday for his speech in which he claimed India hadn't kept its nuclear buttons for Diwali.

The top-polling body also let Congress President Rahul Gandhi go, for calling his BJP counterpart Amit Shah a murder accused at a rally.

Here's what happened.

Clean chit

PM Modi spoke about Pakistan's nuclear threats

PM Modi spoke about Pakistan's nuclear threats

At a rally in Rajasthan, PM Modi said Pakistan kept talking about nuclear bombs every now and then. "What do we have then? Have we kept our nuclear weapons for Diwali," he had asked.

The palpable threat in his tone prompted a complaint. Subsequently, EC said it went through a detailed report sent by Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) of Rajasthan but didn't find violations.

EC said it went through complete transcript of speech

"The matter has been examined in detail in accordance with the extant advisories, provisions of the Model Code of Conduct and after examination of the complete transcript of the speech of 10 pages as per the certified copy sent by the Returning Officer, 17 Barmer Parliamentary Constituency," EC said.

Love Politics news?

Stay updated with the latest happenings.

Yes, notify me

Speech

Separately, Rahul got breather for his attack on Shah

During his public address in Madhya Pradesh's Jabalpur, Rahul called Shah a murder accused.

"Murder accused BJP chief Amit Shah. Waah, kya shaan hai! (What greatness!) Have you heard of Jay Shah? He's a magician; he turned Rs. 50,000 to Rs. 80 crore in three months," he had said.

On this controversial speech, EC said Rahul didn't violate Model Code of Conduct (MCC).

Decision

Earlier, PM Modi got clean-chit despite evoking Balakot strikes

Earlier, PM Modi got clean-chit despite evoking Balakot strikes

PM Modi got his second clean chit for his April 9 speech in Latur, Maharashtra, in which he urged first-time voters to vote for those who conducted Balakot strikes.

The blatant politicization of armed forces got ire and EC sought a response. According to IE, Maharashtra Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) and the Osmanabad District Electoral Officer (DEO) opined he violated the code.

Order

Meanwhile, EC has time till Monday to expedite complaints

Over-ruling the suggestions of its officers, EC concluded that PM Modi didn't seek votes for his party in name of Balakot strikes.

The watchdog also established that CEO and DEO based their opinion on just "five lines of the speech".

As the number of complaints increased, the Supreme Court has directed EC to expedite complaints against Shah and PM Modi by Monday.

Accusations

Congress claimed EC is lenient towards Shah and PM Modi

Congress claimed EC is lenient towards Shah and PM Modi

Meanwhile, Congress has accused EC of being lenient towards Shah and PM Modi.

Spokesperson Pranav Jha called them "habitual offenders" and said, "Rahul Gandhi doesn't have much to worry as he was not trying to garner votes through illegal means. In 11 complaints, it took the EC 30 days to respond to one."

He claimed EC was hurriedly disposing of complaints under SC's pressure.

Response

Subsequently, Jaitley said free speech is equally important

As Congress upped his attack on EC, Union Finance Minister Arun Jaitley said, the party had a history of blackmailing institutions and raising frivolous complaints.

"It (MCC) is subject to free speech. Both have to exist together harmoniously. Is MCC a substitute for free speech? No. MCC is subject of free speech, it does not shrink free speech," Jaitley said on Thursday.

Share this timeline

Amit Shah

Arun Jaitley

Balakot

Election Commission

Narendra Modi

Rahul Gandhi

Supreme Court

Barmer Parliamentary Constituency

CEO

Congress

Congress President Rahul Gandhi

DEO

EC 30

IE

India

Jay Shah

Madhya Pradesh

Maharashtra Chief Electoral Officer

MCC

Model Code

Osmanabad District Electoral Officer

PM Modi

Prime Minister Narendra Modi

Returning Officer

SC

Spokesperson Pranav Jha

Union Finance Minister Arun Jaitley

Share this timeline

Ask NewsBytes
User Image

Most asked questions

Which speech of PM Modi came under scanner recently?

Why did EC give clean chit to PM Modi?

Why was Rahul Gandhi given a clean-chit?

What did Arun Jaitley say about Congress' complaints against BJP?

More questions

Which speech of PM Modi came under scanner recently?

Asked 2019-05-03 11:15:57 by Aradhya Saxena

Answered by NewsBytes

PM Modi said in Rajasthan that India hadn't kept his nuclear bombs for Diwali. This speech invited EC's ire.

Why did EC give clean chit to PM Modi?

Asked 2019-05-03 11:15:57 by Saanvi Subramanium

Answered by NewsBytes

EC said it went through the report of Rajasthan's CEO which carried the complete transcript of PM Modi's speech. After going through it, EC concluded that PM Modi didn't violate Model Code of Conduct (MCC).

Why was Rahul Gandhi given a clean-chit?

Asked 2019-05-03 11:15:57 by Chirag Chatterjee

Answered by NewsBytes

Rahul Gandhi had called Amit Shah a murder accused but he was also given a clean chit. EC said it examined Rahul's speech.

What did Arun Jaitley say about Congress' complaints against BJP?

Asked 2019-05-03 11:15:57 by Ishan Rodrigues

Answered by NewsBytes

Arun Jaitley said Congress had a history of blackmailing institutions and the complaints were frivolous.

Next Timeline