Indonesian woman records boss' lewd calls; gets jail-term

World

06 Jul 2019

Indonesian woman jailed for exposing boss' harassment. What?

People often shift the onus of sexual misconduct onto the victim, demanding explanations, justifications, and action.

Believability is often challenged by the question, "If it really happened, why didn't you report?"

Turns out, that recourse isn't as fruitful as it should be.

An Indonesian woman recorded lewd calls from her boss to present as evidence of sexual harassment and now she's going to jail.

Details

Maknun recorded calls from boss which were later circulated

Maknun recorded calls from boss which were later circulated

Nuril Maknun (41) worked as a part-time bookkeeper at the Senior High School Seven, Mataram.

In 2012, she allegedly started receiving sexually explicit calls from the principal, who goes by the single name Muslim.

Muslim allegedly tried coaxing Maknun into an affair, so she recorded his calls.

The recordings were circulated among school staff, submitted to a local education agency, and went viral online.

Court

Court sentenced Maknun for 'violating decency'

Ironically, in November, the Supreme Court found Maknun guilty of "violating decency" as per Indonesia's electronic information and transactions law in a 2015 case filed by Muslim against her for circulating the recordings.

Muslim reportedly lost his job after the recordings were circulated.

The court also dismissed her judicial review plea to overturn the verdict, because "her crime has been legally and convincingly proven."

Love World news?

Stay updated with the latest happenings.

Yes, notify me

Maknun sentenced to 6 months in jail; slapped with fine

Maknun, who was previously acquitted after spending a month in jail during the investigation, was sentenced to a six-month jail term and a fine of 500 million rupiahs (Rs. 24 lakh) was imposed. She challenged the verdict which was rejected by the SC on Thursday.

Reaction

Verdict 'opens door for sex offenders to criminalize victims'

Verdict 'opens door for sex offenders to criminalize victims'

Now, speaking to Reuters, executive director of the Legal Aid Foundation for the Press, Ade Wahyudin, said, "We are concerned about the impact of this decision because it opens a door for perpetrators of sexual violence to criminalize victims."

"Why can he just casually walk around," Maknun asked, speaking to The New York Times, "while I, as the victim, am the one being punished?"

Maknun denies claims that she circulated recordings

Further, Maknun, whose jail term could be extended if her family fails to pay the fine, has also clarified that a friend at the school took the voice recordings from her phone and leaked them. She said she's not to be blamed for the circulation.

Amnesty

Seeking an official pardon from President is her last option

Evidently, the case sparked widespread outrage across Indonesia, and last year, President Joko Widodo directed Maknun to seek a judicial review, and if that fails, request clemency.

However, Maknun's jail term isn't long enough to qualify for clemency, Aziz Fauzi, one of Maknun's lawyers, clarified to Reuters.

The only option left is asking the President for amnesty and see if he could pardon her.

Maknun is 'ready to accept verdict'

Meanwhile, Maknun is "relatively calm" and "ready to accept the verdict," her lawyer, Joko Jumadi told BBC Indonesian. However, she hopes that she would be the "last victim to face criminal charges" in Indonesia for daring to raise her voice against sexual harassment.

Share this timeline

Crime Against Women

Indonesia

MeToo

Sexual Abuse

Sexual Harassment

Sexual Harassment At Workplace

World

World News

Ade Wahyudin

Aziz Fauzi

BBC Indonesian

Indonesian

Joko Jumadi

Joko Widodo

Legal Aid Foundation

Legal Aid Foundation for the Press

Maknun

New York Times

Nuril Maknun

President Joko Widodo

SC

Senior High School Seven

Supreme Court

Share this timeline

Ask NewsBytes
User Image

Most asked questions

Where did this incident take place?

Why is the victim of sexual harassment going to prison?

What punishment did the court sentence her to?

What options does she have now?

More questions

Where did this incident take place?

Asked 2019-07-06 19:33:58 by Chirag Yadav

Answered by NewsBytes

Nuril Maknun allegedly faced sexual harassment while she was working at the Senior High School Seven in Mataram, Lombok.

Why is the victim of sexual harassment going to prison?

Asked 2019-07-06 19:33:58 by Rishika Sengupta

Answered by NewsBytes

Reportedly, Nuril Maknun recorded lewd calls from her boss, which were later circulated and resulted in him losing his job. In 2015, he lost his job.

What punishment did the court sentence her to?

Asked 2019-07-06 19:33:58 by Surabhi Mehta

Answered by NewsBytes

The court has sentenced her to a jail term of six months and imposed a fine of 500 million rupiahs (Rs. 24.3 lakh).

What options does she have now?

Asked 2019-07-06 19:33:58 by Aditya Chauhan

Answered by NewsBytes

Maknun is only left with one option now and that is to request amnesty from President Joko Widodo.

Next Timeline