'Meritless': OpenAI wants judge to dismiss Apple's trade secrets lawsuit
What's the story
OpenAI has asked a US judge to dismiss Apple's lawsuit accusing it of stealing trade secrets. The AI company called the allegations "meritless," and said they misrepresent the actions of its employees. The case was filed in July, with Apple alleging that OpenAI had secretly acquired its confidential information through former employees, recruiting practices, and supplier relationships.
Defense strategy
OpenAI denies using Apple's trade secrets
In its motion to dismiss, OpenAI emphasized that it has no use or need for Apple's trade secrets. The company is focused on building something different from what Apple does.
It also admitted to hiring some former Apple employees, but clarified that they were attracted by the innovative work at OpenAI.
Evidence presented
Evidence released by OpenAI
OpenAI has countered Apple's claims with evidence.
The company released excerpts of text messages between an unidentified Apple employee and Chang Liu, a former iPhone engineer who joined OpenAI in January.
These messages purport to show that Liu was approached by his former colleagues at Apple seeking help locating information they needed for their work, not stealing trade secrets.
Legal critique
'Baseless lawsuit to cover shortcomings in talent market'
In its court filing, OpenAI criticized Apple's lawsuit for being "plainly filed without adequate investigation and built on selectively excerpted communications and ordinary conduct stripped of context."
The company said the suit misrepresents the lawful conduct of former employees who were trying to help Apple at its request.
It also accused Apple of using a baseless lawsuit to make up for its shortcomings in the talent market.
Court proceedings
Case highlights concerns over protecting ideas
OpenAI has a court-ordered deadline of August 17 to respond to Apple's request for a preliminary injunction.
The judge will hear arguments on the motion on October 1.
The case highlights the ongoing concerns of tech giants like Apple over protecting their ideas as more employees move to rival companies.