Newsbytes
  • India
  • Business
  • World
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Science
  • Entertainment
  • Auto
  • Lifestyle
  • Inspirational
  • Career
  • Bengaluru
  • Delhi
  • Mumbai
  • Videos
  • Phone Reviews
  • Find Cricket Statistics
Hindi
More
Newsbytes
Hindi
Newsbytes
User Placeholder

Hi,

Logout


India
Business
World
Politics
Sports
Science
Entertainment
Auto
Lifestyle
Inspirational
Career
Bengaluru
Delhi
Mumbai
Videos
Phone Reviews
Find Cricket Statistics

More Links
  • Videos

Download Android App

Follow us on
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube
 
Home / News / India News / Everything wrong with CJI Ranjan Gogoi sexual harassment case
  • India

    Everything wrong with CJI Ranjan Gogoi sexual harassment case

    Siddhant Pandey
    Written by
    Siddhant Pandey
    Twitter
    Last updated on May 05, 2019, 07:05 pm
    Everything wrong with CJI Ranjan Gogoi sexual harassment case
  • The Supreme Court of India has become the center of controversy ever since a former employee of the apex court leveled allegations of sexual harassment against the Chief Justice of India Ranjan Gogoi.

    Several senior judges have defended the CJI and with the claims of a conspiracy involving Dawood Ibrahim and Jet Airways, the case gets even murkier and digresses from the original narrative.

  • In this article
    Complainant claims she was sexually harassed, fired and intimidated When the CJI had presided over his own case Justice Gogoi misused CJI status to dismiss allegations Allegations against CJI seen as an attack on judiciary My character damaged without hearing me: Complainant In-house panel not in keeping with Vishakha guidelines, POSH Act Complainant not allowed legal representation, statement recordings No pre-established in-house procedure for CJI as respondent Complainant backed-out of proceedings as justice 'unlikely' Advocate Utsav Bains alleges larger conspiracy to remove CJI Indian judiciary is in peril, alright
  • History

    Complainant claims she was sexually harassed, fired and intimidated

    Complainant claims she was sexually harassed, fired and intimidated
  • According to her complaint, the woman worked in the CJI's office as a junior court assistant from October 2016 to October 2018.

    She claimed the CJI sexually harassed her and later initiated a disciplinary inquiry against her. She was dismissed from service on December 21.

    In March, she was booked under a "false" bribery case.

    Her family was also allegedly intimidated and victimized.

  • Early developments

    When the CJI had presided over his own case

    When the CJI had presided over his own case
  • On April 19, the complainant sent an affidavit to 22 SC judges claiming that the CJI had sexually harassed her and later used intimidation to silence her.

    After three news outlets broke the story, the CJI hastily convened a special bench - comprising himself, Justice Arun Mishra and Justice Sanjiv Khanna - without listing a cause, matter, or a petition.

  • Problems

    Justice Gogoi misused CJI status to dismiss allegations

    Justice Gogoi misused CJI status to dismiss allegations
  • After the Secretary-General of the Supreme Court, Sanjeev S. Kalgaonkar, had already dismissed the allegations as "completely and absolutely false," CJI Gogoi spoke from the Bench in an official capacity, presiding over his own case, and labeled it an attempt to "deactivate the CJI."

    Instead of speaking as the CJI, Justice Gogoi could have approached the press, as he had done in the past.

  • Problems

    Allegations against CJI seen as an attack on judiciary

    Allegations against CJI seen as an attack on judiciary
  • Several senior Justices, the Bar Council of India, the Supreme Court Employees Welfare Association, and the Finance Minister Arun Jaitley condemned the allegations against the CJI as an attack on the judiciary without any investigation whatsoever.

    Four days after the allegations were made, the CJI appointed Justice SA Bobde to head a three-member in-house committee to investigate the claims of sexual harassment.

  • Quote

    My character damaged without hearing me: Complainant

  • The complainant was left "frightened and helpless" after the special sitting held in suo moto proceedings, worried that she'd been "declared false by the Hon'ble Judges and senior law officers." She said, "My character was damaged without any reason and without hearing me."

  • Problems

    In-house panel not in keeping with Vishakha guidelines, POSH Act

    In-house panel not in keeping with Vishakha guidelines, POSH Act
  • The in-house panel initially comprised Justices Bobde, NV Ramana and Indira Banerjee.

    Citing Vishakha guidelines and POSH Act, the complainant requested majority women members on the panel and an external member.

    Meanwhile, Justice Ramana recused himself from the panel but not before further trashing the complainant's claims before she even recorded a statement.

    He was replaced by Justice Indu Malhotra on April 25.

  • Requests

    Complainant not allowed legal representation, statement recordings

    Complainant not allowed legal representation, statement recordings
  • The complainant had also reasonably requested for legal representation.

    She had also demanded a committee of senior retired judges to conduct the inquiry since one conducted by CJI's peers risks lack of objectivity.

    Both requests were denied.

    There was no external member on the committee, as mandated by law.

    Additionally, the request for a video/audio recording of her statements was also denied.

  • Regulations

    No pre-established in-house procedure for CJI as respondent

    No pre-established in-house procedure for CJI as respondent
  • Advocate S. Devika explains that when the Supreme Court adopted the in-house procedure in December 1999 to take remedial action against judges, three sets of procedures were laid out: for judges of the high court, for chief justices of high courts, and for Supreme Court judges.

    Writing for The Wire, Devika states that no procedure was established when the CJI is the respondent.

  • Recent updates

    Complainant backed-out of proceedings as justice 'unlikely'

    Complainant backed-out of proceedings as justice 'unlikely'
  • After participating in the proceedings for three days, the complainant backed-out as she felt she wasn't "likely to get justice."

    "The committee seemed not to appreciate the fact that this was not an ordinary complaint but a complaint of sexual harassment against a sitting CJI," she stated.

    She also wasn't allowed an assistant for her hearing disability and found the "informal proceedings" intimidating.

  • Conspiracy

    Advocate Utsav Bains alleges larger conspiracy to remove CJI

    Advocate Utsav Bains alleges larger conspiracy to remove CJI
  • Separately, on April 20, advocate Utsav Bains alleged a larger conspiracy involving underworld don Dawood Ibrahim and Jet Airways founder Naresh Goyal.

    Bains was allegedly offered Rs. 1.5cr to file a "false case of sexual harassment" against the CJI.

    Retired SC Justice AK Patnaik heads an inquiry into the alleged conspiracy, which has currently been stalled to avoid clashes with Bobde inquiry.

  • Conclusion

    Indian judiciary is in peril, alright

    Indian judiciary is in peril, alright
  • The way this case has transpired, it's become evident that the complainant was prejudged, ironically so by Supreme Court judges, who have failed to look at the case objectively.

    Meanwhile, CJI Gogoi continues to preside over India's highest court giving him access to manipulate the very inquiry against him.

    In a way, whoever said the judiciary is in peril, was right.

  • India
  • Supreme Court Of India
  • Jet Airways
  • Sexual Harassment
  • Dawood Ibrahim
  •  
View all questions (4)
Latest News
  • Taylor Swift reclaims Billboard top spot with 'Fearless (Taylor's Version)'
    Taylor Swift reclaims Billboard top spot with 'Fearless (Taylor's Version)'
    Entertainment
  • NewsBytes Briefing: Domino's leaks all your data, and more
    NewsBytes Briefing: Domino's leaks all your data, and more
    Science
  • #HealthBytes: Few reasons you should regularly go for morning walks
    #HealthBytes: Few reasons you should regularly go for morning walks
    Lifestyle
  • Ahead of launch, Vivo V21 5G's key specifications leaked
    Ahead of launch, Vivo V21 5G's key specifications leaked
    Science
  • Every important upcoming iOS 15 feature you should know about
    Every important upcoming iOS 15 feature you should know about
    Science
Trending Topics
ISRO Vaccine
Next News Article
Share
Cancel

Want to share it with your friends too?

Facebook Whatsapp Twitter Linkedin
Copied

Love India news?

Subscribe to stay updated.

India Thumbnail
India News Business News World News Politics News Sports News Science News Entertainment News Auto News Lifestyle News Inspirational News
Career News Bengaluru News Delhi News Mumbai News Bharti Airtel Mukesh Ambani Indian Premier League Samsung Virat Kohli Rohit Sharma
Cricket News YouTube Hollywood News WhatsApp Bollywood News ISRO Spotify SpaceX Yoga Honda
Batman Football News BMW Vaccine Reliance Jio OPPO Food News, Healthy Recipes Apple Royal Challengers Bangalore Toyota
Fashion Tips Mercedes Sidharth Malhotra Isha Ambani India Vs England Cricket OnePlus Mobiles Android TV Smart TV Marvel Comics Avengers
Delhi Capitals Neha Kakkar X-Men TATA
About Us Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions Contact Us News Reviews News Archive Topics Archive Find Cricket Statistics
Follow us on
Facebook Twitter Linkedin Youtube
All rights reserved © NewsBytes 2021