#KarnatakaFloorTest: Governor asks Kumaraswamy to prove majority by 1:30pm
What's the story
It's D-day for Karnataka Chief Minister HD Kumaraswamy, who has been directed by Governor Vajubhai Vala to prove his coalition's majority on the floor of the assembly by 1:30 PM on Friday. The floor test, scheduled to take place on Thursday, was deferred on speaker KR Ramesh's orders as allies Congress and JD(S) sought "clarity" on resignations of MLAs. Here are all the details.
Context
Backstory: 18 resignations have threatened survival of Kumaraswamy's government
Kumaraswamy's government is hanging by a thread after 18 legislators resigned. By not accepting their resignations immediately, Ramesh gave a window to Congress-JD(S) to "persuade" the rebels. However, the MLAs approached the Supreme Court, which gave its verdict on Wednesday. The apex court said Ramesh can decide on resignation when he wants, but MLAs can't be forced to attend the floor test.
Numbers
But, do the numbers favor Kumaraswamy?
Notably, the numbers don't favor Kumaraswamy. In the last two weeks, 16 legislators- 13 from Congress and three from JD(S) have resigned, while two independents have withdrawn support. Before this crisis, the coalition's strength in the 224-member assembly was 118. If the resignations are accepted, it will become 100, giving an edge to BJP as it already has 105 legislators and support of two independents.
Proceedings
Kumaraswamy moved trust motion, Congress protested, BJP showed urgency
As he moved the motion for a trust vote, Kumaraswamy accused BJP of creating hurdles in governance. When BJP leader BS Yeddyurappa stood up to say the trust vote should be completed in a day, Kumaraswamy taunted by saying, "He seems to be in a hurry". During the debate, Congress protested over Shrimant Patil, who "slipped" from Bengaluru resort where lawmakers were staying and was found at a Mumbai hospital.
Letter
As Ramesh delayed the trust vote, Vala stepped in
Sensing delay in trust vote, BJP met Vala who asked the speaker to conclude the floor test by the end of the day. However, when Ramesh remained undecided on resignations, the Governor stepped in again and wrote a letter to Kumaraswamy. In the letter, also copied to Ramesh, Vala said "prima facie" it looks like the coalition has lost the confidence of the House.
Quote
You have lost majority: Vala told Kumaraswamy
"The fact that 15 members have met me and tendered their resignations and coupled with two members have withdrawn their support and other attendant circumstances do prima facie indicate that you have lost majority/confidence of the House," the letter read.
Details
Further, Vala also raised objection on delay in floor test
Vala also said he hadn't intervened in the matter until now as the motion was moved. But since the House was adjourned without completing the floor test, he was forced to step up. "This cannot go on in a democratic set-up governed by the Constitution of India," Vala's letter read. Meanwhile, Congress' Shivakumar, seen as the party's troubleshooter, confirmed that Vala's letter was received.
Quote
Defending Ramesh, Shivakumar claimed BJP was trying to "put pressure"
"The Speaker is conducting the House, he will have to give MLAs an opportunity to discuss, at such time friends from BJP are trying to put pressure through the Governor's office," Shivakumar reportedly said.
Sleepover
Meanwhile, BJP MLAs spent the night at Vidhan Soudha
The political drama in the state reached another level after Yeddyurappa declared that BJP MLAs won't leave the assembly to protest the delay in the trust vote. "There has been a breach of the constitutional framework," Yeddyurappa said. On Yeddyurappa's command, members of the saffron party had dinner at the Vidhan Soudha, and then brought their beddings and nightwear to sleep inside the House.
Twitter Post
After "long day", Yeddyurappa slept on assembly's floor
विधानसभा या विश्रामसभा?#KarnatakaFloorTest pic.twitter.com/E19iIjAjOt
— Akhilesh Sharma अखिलेश शर्मा (@akhileshsharma1) July 19, 2019