Newsbytes
  • India
  • Business
  • World
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Science
  • Entertainment
  • Auto
  • Lifestyle
  • Inspirational
  • Career
  • Bengaluru
  • Delhi
  • Mumbai
  • Videos
  • Find Cricket Statistics
Hindi
More
Newsbytes
Hindi
Newsbytes
User Placeholder

Hi,

Logout


India
Business
World
Politics
Sports
Science
Entertainment
Auto
Lifestyle
Inspirational
Career
Bengaluru
Delhi
Mumbai
Videos
Find Cricket Statistics

More Links
  • Videos

Download Android App

Follow us on
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube
 
Home / News / Business News / Censorship by Facebook? The story so far
  • Business

    Censorship by Facebook? The story so far

    Shiladitya Ray
    Written by
    Shiladitya Ray
    Mail
    Last updated on Sep 28, 2016, 06:05 pm
    Censorship by Facebook? The story so far
  • In the most recent development to the Facebook censorship issue, seven Palestinian journalists had their accounts blocked without explanation.

    While this issue must be explored in all its nuances, recent accusations levelled at Facebook raises questions regarding its claimed impartiality to content.

  • In this article
    Reactions to the banning of the accounts Shebab News Agency and Quds News Network's anti-Israel links Should Facebook be involved? Facebook's involvement is not apolitical Facebook removes iconic Vietnam War photo The girl in the Vietnam War photo Former Facebook workers reveal censorship of conservative stories Examples of censorship of conservative posts Facebook censors content in India, Pakistan and Turkey Facebook's blocked content data Facebook's algorithm: Code or editor or both? Should Facebook accept its editorial responsibility? Censorship by Facebook? The story so far
  • Reactions

    Reactions to the banning of the accounts

    Reactions to the banning of the accounts
  • The journalists, who worked for the Shebab News Agency and the Quds News Network, claimed that the recent Israel-Facebook agreement, aimed at curbing violence-inciting social media posts, was being exploited to target them.

    Facebook, however, claimed that the pages were "removed in error" and would be restored as soon as it finished conducting its investigation into the issue.

  • Do you know?

    Shebab News Agency and Quds News Network's anti-Israel links

  • The Shebab News Agency and the Quds News Network are quite popular on Facebook, with 6.7 million and 5.1 million followers respectively. However, both publications have a reputation for being linked to anti-Israel militant groups.

  • Implications

    Should Facebook be involved?

    Should Facebook be involved?
  • Admittedly, it is difficult to conclude whether inflammatory posts made by Palestinians are symptoms of the Israel-Palestine conflict or general hate speech - it is a sketchy area.

    While Facebook has a moral responsibility to remove general hate speech, involvement in any political dispute, especially in one as sensitive as the Israel-Palestine issue, would negate Facebook's claimed apolitical stance.

  • Quote

    Facebook's involvement is not apolitical

  • Dr. Thomas Zeitzoff, a professor at the Department of Law, Justice and Criminology at the American University, said that Facebook's decision to enter into the debate of whether posts by Palestinian journalists were causing violence was "not a kind of apolitical, benign move".

  • 09 Sep 2016

    Facebook removes iconic Vietnam War photo

    Facebook removes iconic Vietnam War photo
    Credits:
  • Facebook removed an iconic Vietnam War photo of a naked nine year-old girl fleeing a napalm attack on grounds of nudity.

    Espen Egil Hansen, the editor of Aftenposten, the Norwegian newspaper which circulated the post, said that Facebook's action was an "abuse of power".

    He wrote an open letter to Facebook, harshly criticizing the company's inability to distinguish between child pornography and war photographs.

  • Do you know?

    The girl in the Vietnam War photo

  • The nine year-old girl in the aforementioned Vietnam War photo is Kim Phuc, aged 53 now. She was horribly burned during the attack in which she was photographed, and had to go through 17 operations. Currently, she works as a UN goodwill ambassador.

  • Facebook censorship?

    Former Facebook workers reveal censorship of conservative stories

    Former Facebook workers reveal censorship of conservative stories
    Credits:
  • In May 2016, former Facebook "news curators" revealed that they had often suppressed news stories which involved conservative leaders or could have been of interest to conservative users.

    Moreover, these employees were often asked to "inject" selected stories into users' feeds from a large list of ranked trending topics, thereby tampering with what information a user received.

  • Do you know?

    Examples of censorship of conservative posts

  • The former Facebook employees revealed that they often prevented stories about Conservative leader and ex-Presidential candidate Mitt Romney, Conservative Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky, the Conservative Political Action Conference and others from appearing on Facebook's trending section.

  • Selective blocking

    Facebook censors content in India, Pakistan and Turkey

    Facebook censors content in India, Pakistan and Turkey
  • A 2015 CNN Money report stated that in countries like India, Pakistan and Turkey, Facebook actively blocks varied material, effectively acting as a government censor.

    Facebook's behaviour in these countries results from a dilemma: censor posts or get banned from the country.

    The "pieces of content" which are blocked can still be viewed by users from other countries implying that Facebook selectively blocks material.

  • Data

    Facebook's blocked content data

  • According to the CNN Money report, in the first half of 2014, Facebook blocked around 5,000 "pieces of content" in India, and nearly 2,000 each in Pakistan and Turkey. For comparison, in the same period, only 1 post each was blocked in Kuwait and UAE.

  • Facebook's algorithm

    Facebook's algorithm: Code or editor or both?

    Facebook's algorithm: Code or editor or both?
  • After accusations of political bias, in August 2016, Facebook replaced all its human editors with algorithms.

    However, Facebook engineers regularly check trending stories decided by the algorithms to ensure that inaccurate or sexually explicit posts are not promoted.

    Furthermore, the algorithms are far from "neutral" insofar that they were programmed by designers and thus reflect their biases in the selection and promotion of stories.

  • Editorial responsibility

    Should Facebook accept its editorial responsibility?

    Should Facebook accept its editorial responsibility?
  • In spite of the aforementioned cases and many others like it, Facebook has never accepted editorial responsibility.

    Mark Zuckerberg has repeatedly emphasized that Facebook is "not a media company".

    However, if, as demonstrated, Facebook's algorithm acts as an editorial gatekeeper affecting the nature of news content available to its 1.7 billion users, is it not time for Facebook to take responsibility for the same?

  • 28 Sep 2016

    Censorship by Facebook? The story so far

    Censorship by Facebook? The story so far
  • In the most recent development to the Facebook censorship issue, seven Palestinian journalists had their accounts blocked without explanation.

    While this issue must be explored in all its nuances, recent accusations levelled at Facebook raises questions regarding its claimed impartiality to content.

  • India
  • Facebook
  • Mark Zuckerberg
  • Rand Paul
  • Vietnam War
  •  
Latest News
  • 2021 Volkswagen Arteon sedan to be launched in India soon?
    2021 Volkswagen Arteon sedan to be launched in India soon?
    Auto
  • Use less plastic, more eco-friendly material: PM to toy manufacturers
    Use less plastic, more eco-friendly material: PM to toy manufacturers
    India
  • Anurag Kashyap's daughter Aaliyah opens up about receiving rape threats
    Anurag Kashyap's daughter Aaliyah opens up about receiving rape threats
    Entertainment
  • Pune becomes India's second worst-hit city by COVID-19 after Delhi
    Pune becomes India's second worst-hit city by COVID-19 after Delhi
    India
  • COVID-19: Cabinet Secretary to hold review meeting with eight states
    COVID-19: Cabinet Secretary to hold review meeting with eight states
    India
Trending Topics
Bharti Airtel Mukesh Ambani WhatsApp Reliance Jio OPPO Isha Ambani Gross Domestic Product
Next News Article
Share
Cancel

Want to share it with your friends too?

Facebook Whatsapp Twitter Linkedin
Copied

Love Business news?

Subscribe to stay updated.

Business Thumbnail
India News Business News World News Politics News Sports News Science News Entertainment News Auto News Lifestyle News Inspirational News
Career News Bengaluru News Delhi News Mumbai News Bharti Airtel Mukesh Ambani Indian Premier League Samsung Virat Kohli Rohit Sharma
Cricket News YouTube Hollywood News WhatsApp Bollywood News ISRO Yoga Honda Batman Football News
BMW Vaccine Reliance Jio OPPO Food News, Healthy Recipes Royal Challengers Bangalore Toyota Fashion Tips Farmers Protest Mohammed Bin Salman
Mercedes Europa League Isha Ambani India Vs England Cricket OnePlus Mobiles Android TV Smart TV Marvel Comics Avengers Neha Kakkar
Premier League Big Bang Theory X-Men TATA
About Us Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions Contact Us News Reviews News Archive Topics Archive Find Cricket Statistics
Follow us on
Facebook Twitter Linkedin Youtube
All rights reserved © NewsBytes 2021