NewsBytes
    Hindi Tamil Telugu
    More
    In the news
    Narendra Modi
    Amit Shah
    Box Office Collection
    Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)
    OTT releases
    Hindi Tamil Telugu
    NewsBytes
    User Placeholder

    Hi,

    Logout

    India
    Business
    World
    Politics
    Sports
    Technology
    Entertainment
    Auto
    Lifestyle
    Inspirational
    Career
    Bengaluru
    Delhi
    Mumbai

    Download Android App

    Follow us on
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Linkedin
    Home / News / India News / SC pulls up Prashant Bhushan over "CJIs are corrupt" remark
    Next Article
    SC pulls up Prashant Bhushan over "CJIs are corrupt" remark

    SC pulls up Prashant Bhushan over "CJIs are corrupt" remark

    By Shalini Ojha
    Aug 05, 2020
    12:56 am

    What's the story

    The Supreme Court on Tuesday pulled up noted lawyer Prashant Bhushan while hearing the concluding arguments in a 2009 contempt case, initiated against him by celebrated lawyer Harish Salve.

    A bench, led by Justice Arun Mishra, told Bhushan, who remained stern despite the charges against him, that there was a thin line between free speech and contempt.

    Here's everything that happened inside the court.

    Context

    What was the case all about?

    More than a decade ago, Bhushan found himself in troubled waters after he told journalist Tarun Tejpal, who headed Tehelka magazine at the time, that half of the past 16 chief justices of India were corrupt.

    In 2009, the top court issued notices to Tejpal and Bhushan for their critical opinions against some sitting and former judges.

    Notice

    SC issued notices to Bhushan taking suo motu cognizance

    Last month, Justice Mishra's bench, also including Justices BR Gavai and Krishna Murari, issued suo motu notices to Bhushan in connection to his 2009 remarks and two recent tweets, which supposedly brought disrepute to the judiciary.

    While Bhushan was represented by lawyer Rajeev Dhavan, senior Congress leader Kapil Sibal was Tejpal's representative.

    The hearing was conducted virtually in the wake of COVID-19 pandemic.

    Looking back

    Back then, Bhushan stood by his comments, got father's support

    Notably, Bhushan, through his lawyer late Ram Jethmalani, had maintained his statements at the time don't translate to contempt against court.

    Rejecting his arguments, SC had ordered that the contempt case must proceed.

    In fact, Bhushan's father, former Law Minister Shanti Bhushan, also filed an affidavit, saying he had the same views as his son's regarding corrupt CJIs.

    The last hearing happened in 2012.

    What happened

    When Dhavan suggested closing the case, SC explained its importance

    During today's hearing, Dhavan told the bench that if they looked through Jethmalani's arguments, they would shut the matter.

    But Justice Mishra remarked that this case was about "saving the grace of the system," and he would explain the complexities to Dhavan later.

    Thereafter, all mics were muted and the bench phoned Dhavan. This hints there would be no open hearing in this matter.

    Tweets

    Separately, Bhushan also stood by his two controversial tweets

    Meanwhile, Bhushan has also stood by his tweets which have triggered another case against him. The matter will be heard tomorrow.

    In one tweet, Bhushan posted a photo of CJI SA Bobde, riding a Harley Davidson bike.

    And in another tweet, the lawyer hinted that democracy was destroyed in the last six years under the watch of the last four CJIs.

    Affidavit

    Bhushan filed affidavit defending himself, didn't mention "regret" or "apology"

    Facing serious charges, Bhushan filed an affidavit in SC but didn't express regret.

    Other than admitting that he wrongfully slammed Bobde for not wearing a helmet, when the bike wasn't moving, Bhushan said he did nothing wrong.

    Defending himself, he wrote, "To assume and suggest that 'CJI is the SC, and SC is the CJI', is to undermine the institution of SC."

    Quote

    Free and frank conversation needed in democracy: Bhushan

    "In any healthy democracy, there needs to be a free and frank discussion about the role of any and every institution, especially an institution as critical as the Supreme Court," Bhushan told the court through his 134-page affidavit.

    Facebook
    Whatsapp
    Twitter
    Linkedin
    Related News
    Latest
    Supreme Court Of India
    Prashant Bhushan
    Rajeev Dhavan
    BR Gavai

    Latest

    Supreme Court acquits man sentenced to death for 3-year-old's rape-murderĀ  Bombay High Court
    Chivanga replaces injured Gwandu in Zimbabwe's one-off Test versus England Zimbabwe Cricket Team
    Decoding scenario of overseas players for remainder of IPL 2025 Gujarat Titans
    Chris Brown's UK assault case moved to higher court Chris Brown

    Supreme Court Of India

    SC doesn't order to restore 4G Internet services in J&K Jammu And Kashmir
    No action against employers for not paying wages: Supreme Court Ministry Of Home Affairs
    Can't stop migrant workers from walking: SC on Aurangabad incident Madhya Pradesh
    Cabinet gives ex-post facto nod to domicile law in J&K Narendra Modi

    Prashant Bhushan

    Geeta Johri of Sohrabuddin infamy becomes Guj DGP Central Bureau Of Investigation (CBI)
    Delhi MCD 2017 Elections commence Delhi
    Drama in SC: CJI Misra overturns order on judges' bribery-case India
    Judges bribery scam: SC dismisses plea to form SIT Supreme Court Of India

    Rajeev Dhavan

    Ayodhya-verdict: How SC's judgment could change Babri Masjid dispute India
    It's torture: Muslim party opposes daily hearings of Ayodhya case Supreme Court Of India
    Ayodhya case: Muslim party's advocate alleges his clerk was assaulted Supreme Court Of India
    Ayodhya case: Muslims' lawyer tears map, CJI says "we'll leave" Supreme Court Of India

    BR Gavai

    SC rejects Tarun Tejpal's plea to cancel sexual harassment charges Supreme Court Of India
    'Four-month-old goes to protest': Shaheen Bagh's infant death angers SC Supreme Court Of India
    Consider home delivery of alcohol during lockdown: SC tells states Zomato
    Indian Premier League (IPL) Celebrity Hollywood Bollywood UEFA Champions League Tennis Football Smartphones Cryptocurrency Upcoming Movies Premier League Cricket News Latest automobiles Latest Cars Upcoming Cars Latest Bikes Upcoming Tablets
    About Us Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions Contact Us Ethical Conduct Grievance Redressal News News Archive Topics Archive Download DevBytes Find Cricket Statistics
    Follow us on
    Facebook Twitter Linkedin
    All rights reserved © NewsBytes 2025