Nikhil Gupta, an Indian national, will find out his sentence on November 20 after admitting to plotting the murder of Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, a Khalistani separatist with US and Canadian citizenship.
Prosecutors are seeking 24 years in prison, saying the plan was a serious threat against a US citizen.
Judge Victor Marrero is set to decide Gupta's fate.
Nikhil Gupta allegedly brokered $100,000 hit
Gupta worked with an Indian government employee and allegedly brokered the deal for $100,000 for the hit.
His lawyers are asking for a lighter sentence, pointing to his clean record and struggles with alcoholism at the time.
In court, Gupta expressed regret and said he's grateful no one was hurt.
Prosecutors argue that a tough sentence is needed to show how serious this kind of crime is and discourage others from trying something similar.