'You're corrupt': SC while reserving order on ex-minister's bail plea
What's the story
The Supreme Court has reserved its verdict on the bail plea of former West Bengal Education Minister Partha Chatterjee, accused in a money laundering case in connection with the state's cash-for-jobs scam. The bench of Justices Surya Kant and Ujjal Bhuyan heard arguments from both sides. Additional Solicitor General SV Raju, appearing for the Enforcement Directorate (ED), opposed Chatterjee's bail plea, saying his role in the scam was significant.
Bail opposition
Court questions Chatterjee's bail plea
Senior Advocate Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for Chatterjee, argued against the ASG's reasoning. He said, "This is just sadistic pleasure. Everybody else has got bail." Justice Kant, however, countered that other accused weren't ministers. Justice Kant said during the hearing, "On the face of it you are a corrupt person! What message you want us to send to society? That corrupt persons can get bail like this?"
Case details
Allegations and arguments in Chatterjee's case
The allegations against Chatterjee pertain to bribe money taken from Class-IV employees and assistant primary teachers. The proceeds were allegedly diverted to dummy companies and proxy persons. Properties were reportedly purchased in joint names with Arpita Mukherjee, a close associate. Rohatgi cited recent judgments granting bail in similar cases due to delayed trials. However, ASG Raju mentioned a supplementary chargesheet filed recently and potential charges framing within four months if Chatterjee cooperates.
Bail denial
Supreme Court's concerns and Chatterjee's bail denial
Chatterjee has been in custody since July 2022 after his arrest by the ED. His plea emphasized his two-year detention and health concerns due to age. The Supreme Court had earlier raised concerns over long custody without trial and low conviction rates in ED cases. Though it was inclined to grant bail, the SC sought details of Chatterjee's custody period in related CBI cases before taking a call.