NewsBytes
    Hindi Tamil Telugu
    More
    In the news
    Shashi Tharoor
    Aam Aadmi Party (AAP)
    Arvind Kejriwal
    Mamata Banerjee
    Nitin Gadkari
    Rahul Gandhi
    Indian National Congress (INC)
    NewsBytes
    Hindi Tamil Telugu
    NewsBytes
    User Placeholder

    Hi,

    Logout


    India Business World Politics Sports Technology Entertainment Auto Lifestyle Inspirational Career Bengaluru Delhi Mumbai Visual Stories Find Cricket Statistics Phones Reviews Fitness Bands Reviews Speakers Reviews

    Download Android App

    Follow us on
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Linkedin
     
    Home / News / Politics News / Implementing Citizenship Act not a choice: MHA tells 'revolting' states
    Politics

    Implementing Citizenship Act not a choice: MHA tells 'revolting' states

    Implementing Citizenship Act not a choice: MHA tells 'revolting' states
    Written by Shalini Ojha
    Dec 14, 2019, 05:45 pm 3 min read
    Implementing Citizenship Act not a choice: MHA tells 'revolting' states

    In stern words, the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) has told states that implementing the Citizenship Act is not a choice, and they will have to follow the law of the land. This came after Chief Ministers of five states, namely Punjab, West Bengal, Kerala, Chhattisgarh, and Madhya Pradesh, said they will not implement the new law. Here are more details.

    Why is there anger against the Citizenship Act?

    The Citizenship Act will give Indian citizenship to persecuted non-Muslims from Bangladesh, Afghanistan, and Pakistan. Those who opposed the Bill in the Parliament said it went against the secular nature of India, was bigoted, and was nowhere close to what our forefathers envisioned for this country. Meanwhile, protests broke out in the Northeast as citizens feared more Bangladeshi immigrants might settle in the area.

    CMs of states spoke about defying Citizenship Act

    After the Bill was passed in the Rajya Sabha on Thursday, Punjab Chief Minister Captain Amarinder Singh announced his state will opt out of the "unethical" law. His Kerala counterpart Pinarayi Vijayan also called it divisive and claimed the Centre wanted to divert attention from pressing matters. Similarly, Trinamool matriarch and West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee said neither CAB nor NRC will be implemented.

    Korbey na, korbey na, korbey na: Mamata

    "Passing the law does not mean anything. Implementation will be up to the state government. Our government is here, korbey na, korbey na, korbey na (will not do it, thrice over," Mamata said, according to The Telegraph.

    Similarly, MP CM said federal structure is at stake

    On Friday, Chhattisgarh and MP, both governed by Congress leaders Bhupesh Baghel and Kamal Nath respectively, also joined the bandwagon. "I cannot help sow the seeds of divisiveness. The federal structure is at stake; the Centre should have consulted with the chief ministers before going ahead with this," Nath said. And Baghel told his stand will not be different from that of Congress.

    States can't say no to a central law: MHA official

    Amid the dissent, a Home Ministry official said states don't have a choice. "States have no power to say 'no' to a central law, which now comes under the 7th Schedule of the Constitution. No state government is empowered to deny or halt its implementation. Granting citizenship is the Centre's prerogative," the official said. Interestingly, a senior lawyer named Anupam Lal Das concurred.

    Centre has exclusive domain to frame laws: Das

    "There are three lists under the seventh schedule - union, concurrent and state. Centre has an exclusive domain to frame laws on matters falling under the union list and citizenship is one such subject," senior Supreme Court lawyer Das told HT.

    They can't defy it, but can delay it

    However, Das pointed out that states can delay the implementation citing law and order. "States can turn around and say they will not conduct any enumeration exercise as a precautionary measure to maintain public order," he explained. Meanwhile, another lawyer, Sanjay Hegde, said the option of approaching the Supreme Court is always open. He said states have filed civil suits against Centre previously too.

    Interestingly, CMs might lose their chairs if they challenge Centre

    While some CMs have been condemning the Citizenship Act, it might cost them their power. If a state chooses to disobey a parliamentary enactment, the governor can recommend President's Rule under Article 356 of the constitution. Though there are provisions to protect the state governments from arbitrary dismissals, citizenship is a Central matter, which means BJP has an upper hand here.

    Share this timeline
    Facebook
    Whatsapp
    Twitter
    Linkedin
    Latest
    West Bengal
    Ministry Of Home Affairs
    Madhya Pradesh
    Punjab

    Latest

    Congress conspiring to use Rahul's conviction for Karnataka polls: BJP Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)
    Highlights from Smriti Irani's appearance on 'The Slow Interview' Smriti Irani
    Dress for success: 5 professional attire tips for women Workplace
    Zimbabwe win 3rd ODI, claim series against Netherlands: Stats Zimbabwe Cricket Team

    West Bengal

    BJP trying to make Rahul Gandhi hero, says Mamata Banerjee Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)
    Rahul Gandhi is PM Modi's biggest TRP: Mamata Banerjee Mamata Banerjee
    5 historical places to visit on your trip to Burdwan Travel And Tourism
    IMD predicts rainfall, thunderstorms in several states; farmers alerted India Meteorological Department (IMD)

    Ministry Of Home Affairs

    Delhi Police files case over pro-Khilastan protest in London Delhi Police
    Centre's objection to budget 'unconstitutional': Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal Arvind Kejriwal
    Centre initiates process to ban over 230 Chinese apps: Report Central Government
    Ladakh: Sonam Wangchuk to launch hunger strike demanding constitutional safeguards Ladakh

    Madhya Pradesh

    Chhattisgarh: 5-year-old boy appointed as 'child constable' after father's death  Chhattisgarh
    Madhya Pradesh: 2 women marry same man on one condition Gwalior
    Bhopal Gas Tragedy: Setback for Centre; SC dismisses compensation plea Supreme Court Of India
    Madhya Pradesh: School staff booked for teaching Bible to students Child Welfare Committee

    Punjab

    Haryana woman arrested for sheltering Amritpal Singh and his aide Haryana
    Amritpal may have fled Punjab, vigil along Nepal border increased Khalistani
    Amritpal Singh's gunman arrested, was among accused in Ajnala case Punjab Police
    Navjot Singh Sidhu's wife suffering from cancer, pens emotional note Navjot Singh Sidhu

    Love Politics News?

    Subscribe to stay updated.

    Politics Thumbnail
    Indian Premier League (IPL) Celebrity Hollywood Bollywood UEFA Champions League Tennis Football Smartphones Cryptocurrency Upcoming Movies Premier League Cricket News Latest automobiles Latest Cars Upcoming Cars Latest Bikes Upcoming Tablets
    About Us Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions Contact Us Ethical Conduct Grievance Redressal News News Archive Topics Archive Download DevBytes Find Cricket Statistics
    Follow us on
    Facebook Twitter Linkedin
    All rights reserved © NewsBytes 2023