Newsbytes
  • India
  • Business
  • World
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Auto
  • Lifestyle
  • Inspirational
  • Career
  • Bengaluru
  • Delhi
  • Mumbai
  • Videos
  • Visual Stories
  • Reviews
  • Phone Reviews
  • Fitness Bands Reviews
  • Speakers Reviews
  • Find Cricket Statistics
Hindi
More
In the news
Enforcement Directorate (ED)
ITR Deadline
Coronavirus India
Coronavirus Cases In India
Money Laundering Case
Sidhu Moose Wala
Newsbytes
Hindi
Newsbytes
User Placeholder

Hi,

Logout


India
Business
World
Politics
Sports
Technology
Entertainment
Auto
Lifestyle
Inspirational
Career
Bengaluru
Delhi
Mumbai
Videos
Visual Stories
Reviews
Phone Reviews
Fitness Bands Reviews
Speakers Reviews
Find Cricket Statistics

More Links
  • Videos

Download Android App

Follow us on
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube
 
Home / News / India News / #RafaleDeal: Former ministers call for review of SC's decision
India

#RafaleDeal: Former ministers call for review of SC's decision

#RafaleDeal: Former ministers call for review of SC's decision
Written by Shiladitya Ray
Jan 02, 2019, 01:45 pm 4 min read
#RafaleDeal: Former ministers call for review of SC's decision

Half a month after the Supreme Court gave a clean chit to the government on the controversial Rafale deal, former ministers Arun Shourie and Yashwant Sinha, along with activist lawyer Prashant Bhushan, have requested the apex court for a review of its decision. The trio's petition holds that the SC's verdict had relied on incorrect claims made by the Center, and hence requires review.

Verdict
What the SC had observed in its December 14 verdict

On December 14, the SC said that it had found the Center's decision-making process in the deal 'satisfactory'. The SC's decision had been based on filings by the Center that claimed that a report on the deal's pricing by the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) had been submitted to and had been reviewed by the Parliament's Public Accounts Committee (PAC).

Quote
The all important paragraph from the SC verdict

"The pricing details have, however, been shared with the Comptroller and Auditor General...and the report of the CAG has been examined by the Public Accounts Committee...Only a redacted portion of the report was placed before the Parliament, and is in public domain," read an excerpt from the verdict.

Misleading?
Why the Center's filings have been deemed to be misleading

Turned out, no such CAG report had been submitted to the PAC. Several PAC members, including PAC chairman Mallikarjun Kharge, BJD MP Bhartruhari Mahtab, and Congress MP Rajeev Gowda confirmed that no such report had been submitted to the PAC, let alone reviewed by it. This, of course raised questions about whether the Center deliberately misled the Supreme Court to avoid a court-led inquiry.

Response
How the Center had responded to questions being raised

Once questions were raised, the Center responded by filing an affidavit in the SC. In the affidavit, the Center claimed that the SC had misinterpreted its filing, which had been submitted in a sealed cover. The affidavit claimed that the Center only highlighted the procedure, and did not say that the CAG report had already been reviewed by the PAC.

Political storm
A war of words had broken out between BJP, Congress

Subsequently, a political storm had broken out. The BJP had initially flaunted the SC verdict as a vindication of the Modi government, and had demanded an apology from Congress chief Rahul Gandhi for his allegations of corruption. After the Center's faulty filing came to light, RaGa accused the Center of lying to the SC, and undermining the apex court, which is a sacrosanct institution.

Timing
The call for a review comes after PM Modi's interview

Given the dubious basis on which the SC verdict had been based, Sinha, Shourie, Bhushan have not just called for a review of the SC verdict, but have also called for an oral hearing of their petition in an open court. Notably, the move comes a day after Prime Minister Narendra Modi, in an interview with ANI, dismissed claims of crony capitalism against his government.

Fresh details
Fresh details, too, have emerged about the Rafale deal

It also comes on a day when the Rafale deal is slated to be debated in the Lok Sabha. Interestingly, The Wire has also uncovered fresh facts about the Rafale deal, wherein it has been found that the Prime Minister's Office (PMO) had compromised the negotiating position of the defense ministry during negotiations. Notably, these 'problems' caused by the PMO have been officially documented.

Intervention
The defense ministry had flagged the PMO's intervention as problematic

In its report, The Wire said internal memos circulated within the defense ministry flagged the PMO's intervention in proceedings as problematic. As per procedure, the defense ministry's contract negotiating team is supposed to independently assess purchases of defense equipment. However, the internal memos indicate that the PMO intervened at a crucial stage, and even diluted the requirement for a sovereign guarantee from France.

Resistance
The deal had been resisted by many on the inside

These interventions primarily took place in December 2015, when the law ministry had said that a sovereign guarantee was a necessity for the deal. Meanwhile, it has also been reported that the increased benchmark price of 36 Rafale jets had been resisted by the defense ministry's negotiating team before it was sent to the Cabinet Committee on Security (CCS) for approval.

Manohar Parrikar
Reportedly, Parrikar had not signed off certain aspects

Further, it has also been learnt that then defense minister Manohar Parrikar had not signed off on the increased benchmark price for the 36 Rafale jets, which had risen from €5.2bn earlier to €8.2bn. Neither had he approved the dilution of a sovereign guarantee from France to a mere letter of comfort.

Share this timeline
Facebook
Whatsapp
Twitter
Linkedin
Shiladitya Ray
Shiladitya Ray
Mail
Budding social scientist with a keen interest in social studies of science and the sociology of knowledge. Cinephile. Liverpudlian. Metalhead.
Latest
Supreme Court Of India
Narendra Modi
Lok Sabha
Manohar Parrikar
Rahul Gandhi
Latest
Netflix's latest series 'The Sandman' is unmissable. Here's why
Netflix's latest series 'The Sandman' is unmissable. Here's why Entertainment
Teclast P30 Air, with MediaTek chipset and Android 12, launched
Teclast P30 Air, with MediaTek chipset and Android 12, launched Technology
2023 Ford Explorer breaks cover in China: Check design, features
2023 Ford Explorer breaks cover in China: Check design, features Auto
All you need to know about 'Jhalak Dikhhla Jaa S10'
All you need to know about 'Jhalak Dikhhla Jaa S10' Entertainment
TECNO CAMON 19 Pro 5G's India launch on August 10
TECNO CAMON 19 Pro 5G's India launch on August 10 Technology
Supreme Court Of India
UP: MP cleared of rape charges, year after victim's suicide
UP: MP cleared of rape charges, year after victim's suicide India
SC mulls amending abortion law to include unmarried women
SC mulls amending abortion law to include unmarried women India
SC asks EC not to decide on 'real' Shiv Sena
SC asks EC not to decide on 'real' Shiv Sena Politics
Thackeray claims original Sena with him; Shinde camp denies defection
Thackeray claims original Sena with him; Shinde camp denies defection Politics
SC Collegium holds rare 75-minute meeting, mulls over next CJI
SC Collegium holds rare 75-minute meeting, mulls over next CJI India
More News
Narendra Modi
Bihar: CM Nitish Kumar rings Gandhi as BJP-JD(U) rift widens
Bihar: CM Nitish Kumar rings Gandhi as BJP-JD(U) rift widens Politics
Rajasthan: Stampede at Khatu Shyamji leaves 3 dead, several injured
Rajasthan: Stampede at Khatu Shyamji leaves 3 dead, several injured India
Meet 'son of soil' Jagdeep Dhankhar, India's 14th Vice President
Meet 'son of soil' Jagdeep Dhankhar, India's 14th Vice President Politics
PM to chair NITI Aayog meet today; KCR to boycott
PM to chair NITI Aayog meet today; KCR to boycott Politics
Jagdeep Dhankhar is India's 14th vice president
Jagdeep Dhankhar is India's 14th vice president Politics
More News
Lok Sabha
From not eating onions to UPA barbs, Sitharaman's shocking comments
From not eating onions to UPA barbs, Sitharaman's shocking comments Politics
Suspension of 4 Congress MPs revoked; price rise debate begins
Suspension of 4 Congress MPs revoked; price rise debate begins Politics
Ruckus in Lok Sabha over addressing President Murmu as 'Rashtrapatni'
Ruckus in Lok Sabha over addressing President Murmu as 'Rashtrapatni' Politics
Parliament monsoon session: 19 opposition Rajya Sabha MPs suspended
Parliament monsoon session: 19 opposition Rajya Sabha MPs suspended Politics
'Unruly behavior': 4 Congress MPs suspended for entire monsoon session
'Unruly behavior': 4 Congress MPs suspended for entire monsoon session Politics
More News
Manohar Parrikar
Goa: Pramod Sawant resigns, suspense over CM post continues
Goa: Pramod Sawant resigns, suspense over CM post continues Politics
Goa CM Pramod Sawant tests coronavirus positive, in home isolation
Goa CM Pramod Sawant tests coronavirus positive, in home isolation Politics
He used my father's ill health, Parrikar's son slams Gandhi
He used my father's ill health, Parrikar's son slams Gandhi Politics
Goa: 4 ministers, including 3 ex-Congress MLAs, included in Cabinet
Goa: 4 ministers, including 3 ex-Congress MLAs, included in Cabinet Politics
Rape accused Goa lawmaker among 10 MLAs to join BJP
Rape accused Goa lawmaker among 10 MLAs to join BJP Politics
More News
Rahul Gandhi
Witnessing democracy's death: Rahul as Congress marches to Rashtrapati Bhavan
Witnessing democracy's death: Rahul as Congress marches to Rashtrapati Bhavan Politics
Enforcement Directorate seals National Herald office just day after raids
Enforcement Directorate seals National Herald office just day after raids Politics
'National Herald' case: ED raids 12 locations after questioning Gandhis
'National Herald' case: ED raids 12 locations after questioning Gandhis Politics
Irani case: Delhi HC orders Congress leaders to remove tweets
Irani case: Delhi HC orders Congress leaders to remove tweets Politics
SC upholds ED's powers to arrest under money laundering act
SC upholds ED's powers to arrest under money laundering act India
More News
Next News Article
Next News Article

Love India news?

Subscribe to stay updated.

India Thumbnail
India News Business News World News Politics News Sports News Technology News Entertainment News Auto News Lifestyle News Inspirational News
Career News Bengaluru News Delhi News Mumbai News Mukesh Ambani Indian Premier League (IPL) Karnataka Samsung Xiaomi West Bengal
Bihar Virat Kohli Rohit Sharma Haryana Narendra Modi Arvind Kejriwal Tamil Nadu Gujarat Yogi Adityanath YouTube
Instagram Hollywood News Uttar Pradesh Kerala Netflix Bollywood News Mamata Banerjee Maruti Suzuki Rahul Gandhi Elon Musk
Shah Rukh Khan Chelsea FC OPPO Akhilesh Yadav Indian Cricket Team Apple Manchester United Salman Khan Cryptocurrency OnePlus
Amitabh Bachchan ICC Women's World Cup Vivo India vs Sri Lanka
About Us Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions Contact Us Ethical Conduct Grievance Redressal News News Archive Topics Archive IPL 2022 Schedule IPL 2022 Points Table Find Cricket Statistics
Follow us on
Facebook Twitter Linkedin Youtube
All rights reserved © NewsBytes 2022