Newsbytes
  • India
  • Business
  • World
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Auto
  • Lifestyle
  • Inspirational
  • Career
  • Bengaluru
  • Delhi
  • Mumbai
  • Videos
  • Visual Stories
  • Reviews
  • Phone Reviews
  • Fitness Bands Reviews
  • Speakers Reviews
  • Find Cricket Statistics
Hindi
More
In the news
Indian Premier League (IPL)
UEFA Champions League
Tennis
Test Cricket
Football
Madrid Open
La Liga
Newsbytes
Hindi
Newsbytes
User Placeholder

Hi,

Logout


India
Business
World
Politics
Sports
Technology
Entertainment
Auto
Lifestyle
Inspirational
Career
Bengaluru
Delhi
Mumbai
Videos
Visual Stories
Reviews
Phone Reviews
Fitness Bands Reviews
Speakers Reviews
Find Cricket Statistics

More Links
  • Videos

Download Android App

Follow us on
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube
 
Home / News / Sports News / #NewsBytesExplainer: All you need to know about 'soft signal' rule
Sports

#NewsBytesExplainer: All you need to know about 'soft signal' rule

#NewsBytesExplainer: All you need to know about 'soft signal' rule
Written by Parth Dhall
Mar 19, 2021, 02:50 pm 3 min read
#NewsBytesExplainer: All you need to know about 'soft signal' rule

India made a stunning comeback in the five-match T20I series by winning the fourth match. They claimed an eight-run victory in an attempt to defend 186 runs. Top-order batsman Suryakumar Yadav headlined the match, having smashed a blistering 57 (31). However, some unusual dismissals sparked a debate on the bizarre rule of "soft signal". Let us try to decode the same.

Dismissals
4th T20I: Suryakumar, Washington suffered due to this rule

In the match, Suryakumar was caught by Dawid Malan. However, replays showed that the ball certainly touched the ground. Despite referring to third umpire, the on-field umpire initially gave soft signal as out. Due to inconclusive evidence, the decision couldn't be overturned. Similarly, Washington Sundar was given out even though Adil Rashid's foot appeared to have touched the boundary-rope while taking the catch.

Inception
What is the 'soft signal' rule?

During tight calls in a match, concerning catches, the on-field umpire has to come up with a decision based purely out of intuition before going to the third umpire. Thereafter, the TV umpire views every possible replay in slow motion in order to come up with a conclusion. However, in case of inconclusive evidence, the original decision of on-field umpire stands.

Information
The rule as per ICC's playing conditions

According to the ICC's playing conditions, the soft signal is a "visual communication by the bowler's end umpire to the third umpire (accompanied by additional information via two-way radio where necessary) of his/her initial on-field decision prior to initiating an Umpire Review".

Decision
Can the soft signal be overturned?

As per the rule, the soft signal can only be overturned if the TV umpire finds a decisive evidence. In Suryakumar's case, the on-field umpire gave soft signal as out because he wasn't sure about the dismissal. However, the replays couldn't release any conclusive evidence that the ball touched the ground. Hence, the decision of on-field umpire wasn't overturned and remained intact.

Rule
Can't this rule be eliminated?

There have been several arguments regarding the elimination of this rule. However, one should also understand its requirement. Amid the controversy, Indian commentator Harsha Bhogle shared an interesting analysis. He explained that the soft signal has to be used in such cases as the clips shown to third umpire are two-dimensional representations. Therefore, the view of on-field umpire needs to be taken into account.

Twitter Post
Here is what he tweeted

The reason an umpire has to give a soft signal is documented. On the replays, even clean catches look not out because it is a 2D image of a 3D event. Hence, umpires look at whether the fingers are under the ball. It is a grey area but tech has no answer for now. Need 3D cameras?

— Harsha Bhogle (@bhogleharsha) March 18, 2021
Criticism
The rule has drawn a lot of criticism

After the fourth T20I, the rule drew a lot of flak. "I don't how the on-field umpire can see that when the fielder makes a catch on the boundary," said former England captain Michael Atherton. Former India wicket-keeper Parthiv Patel opined, "I don't think cricket needs soft signal. If you're unsure, go to third umpire and tell 'you make your own decision'."

Views
Kohli, MCC World Cricket Committee echo similar views

Speaking after the win, Virat Kohli said, "I don't know why there cannot be a sort of 'I don't know' call." Interestingly, Kohli echoes the views of MCC's World Cricket Committee, which recently stated, "For such catches (outfield), the on-field umpires could give an 'unsighted' instruction to the TV umpire, rather than the more explicit soft signal of 'out' or 'not out'."

Share this timeline
Facebook
Whatsapp
Twitter
Linkedin
Parth Dhall
Parth Dhall
Twitter
Parth Dhall covers sports news for NewsBytes. He has previously worked with Cricket Today and Follow Your Sport. In a career spanning over five years, Parth has written for several other publications, including IANS, The Statesman, Sportskeeda. He holds a Bachelor's degree in Journalism and Mass Communication from the Vivekananda Institute of Professional Studies (VIPS) of Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University.
Latest
Virat Kohli
Cricket: News, Stats and more!
India vs England Cricket
Suryakumar Yadav
England tour of India (2021)
Related
Latest
Tata Tiago and Tigor become costlier in India: Check prices
Tata Tiago and Tigor become costlier in India: Check prices Auto
IPL 2022, MI vs KKR: Preview, stats, and Fantasy XI
IPL 2022, MI vs KKR: Preview, stats, and Fantasy XI Sports
Karnataka: Setback for Congress as senior leader joins BJP
Karnataka: Setback for Congress as senior leader joins BJP Politics
Cyclone Asani to change course, miss Odisha-Andhra coast: IMD
Cyclone Asani to change course, miss Odisha-Andhra coast: IMD India
IPL 2022, SRH vs RCB: Faf elects to bat
IPL 2022, SRH vs RCB: Faf elects to bat Sports
Virat Kohli
IPL 2022, Rohit Sharma vs Virat Kohli: Decoding the stats
IPL 2022, Rohit Sharma vs Virat Kohli: Decoding the stats Sports
IPL 2022: Gujarat Titans beat RCB, race to 16 points
IPL 2022: Gujarat Titans beat RCB, race to 16 points Sports
IPL 2022: Decoding the performance of SRH pacer Umran Malik
IPL 2022: Decoding the performance of SRH pacer Umran Malik Sports
IPL 2022: All-round SRH blow RCB away in style
IPL 2022: All-round SRH blow RCB away in style Sports
Virat Kohli completes 100 matches without a century: Key stats
Virat Kohli completes 100 matches without a century: Key stats Sports
More News
Cricket: News, Stats and more!
ICC Rankings: Babar tops ODI charts, Allen gains in T20Is
ICC Rankings: Babar tops ODI charts, Allen gains in T20Is Sports
England players forced to self-isolate return for Pakistan T20Is
England players forced to self-isolate return for Pakistan T20Is Sports
ICC World Test Championship 2021-23: Here are the major details
ICC World Test Championship 2021-23: Here are the major details Sports
England chase down 332-run target against Pakistan: Records broken
England chase down 332-run target against Pakistan: Records broken Sports
Ireland stun South Africa in 2nd ODI: Records broken
Ireland stun South Africa in 2nd ODI: Records broken Sports
More News
India vs England Cricket
India set to host SA for five T20Is: Details here
India set to host SA for five T20Is: Details here Sports
England vs India: Fifth Test rescheduled to July 2022
England vs India: Fifth Test rescheduled to July 2022 Sports
ENGvIND: Abandoned Manchester Test to be played next year
ENGvIND: Abandoned Manchester Test to be played next year Sports
India could play two extra T20Is in England next year
India could play two extra T20Is in England next year Sports
England vs India 2021: Decoding the major numbers
England vs India 2021: Decoding the major numbers Sports
More News
Suryakumar Yadav
IPL 2022: MI succumb to a fourth successive defeat
IPL 2022: MI succumb to a fourth successive defeat Sports
IPL 2022, Mumbai Indians: Squad, schedule, and stats
IPL 2022, Mumbai Indians: Squad, schedule, and stats Sports
Decoding the stats of Shreyas Iyer at number three
Decoding the stats of Shreyas Iyer at number three Sports
Decoding Suryakumar Yadav's performance in T20 cricket
Decoding Suryakumar Yadav's performance in T20 cricket Sports
Suryakumar Yadav, Venkatesh Iyer gain in latest ICC T20I Rankings
Suryakumar Yadav, Venkatesh Iyer gain in latest ICC T20I Rankings Sports
More News
England tour of India (2021)
Quarantine, bio-secure bubbles improved bond between Kohli and Rohit: Report
Quarantine, bio-secure bubbles improved bond between Kohli and Rohit: Report Sports
England tour of India 2021: Here are the key stats
England tour of India 2021: Here are the key stats Sports
Will have England Test series in mind going forward: Bhuvneshwar
Will have England Test series in mind going forward: Bhuvneshwar Sports
3rd ODI, India beat England, win series 2-1: Records broken
3rd ODI, India beat England, win series 2-1: Records broken Sports
3rd ODI: India, England register most sixes in three-match series
3rd ODI: India, England register most sixes in three-match series Sports
More News
Related
India vs WI: Mayank added to squad after COVID-19 cases
India vs WI: Mayank added to squad after COVID-19 cases Sports
Spectators to be allowed for India versus West Indies T20Is
Spectators to be allowed for India versus West Indies T20Is Sports
England vs India: Sundar, Gill ruled out of Test series
England vs India: Sundar, Gill ruled out of Test series Sports
Shaw and Suryakumar to join Team India in England
Shaw and Suryakumar to join Team India in England Sports
Next News Article
Next News Article

Love Sports news?

Subscribe to stay updated.

Sports Thumbnail
India News Business News World News Politics News Sports News Technology News Entertainment News Auto News Lifestyle News Inspirational News
Career News Bengaluru News Delhi News Mumbai News Mukesh Ambani Indian Premier League (IPL) Karnataka Samsung Xiaomi West Bengal
Bihar Virat Kohli Rohit Sharma Haryana Narendra Modi Arvind Kejriwal Tamil Nadu Gujarat Yogi Adityanath YouTube
Instagram Hollywood News Uttar Pradesh Kerala Netflix Bollywood News Mamata Banerjee Maruti Suzuki Rahul Gandhi Elon Musk
Shah Rukh Khan Chelsea FC OPPO Akhilesh Yadav Indian Cricket Team Apple Manchester United Salman Khan Cryptocurrency OnePlus
Amitabh Bachchan ICC Women's World Cup Vivo India vs Sri Lanka
About Us Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions Contact Us Ethical Conduct Grievance Redressal News News Archive Topics Archive IPL 2022 Schedule IPL 2022 Points Table Find Cricket Statistics
Follow us on
Facebook Twitter Linkedin Youtube
All rights reserved © NewsBytes 2022