Vaughan, Waugh dismiss controversy over Jaiswal's dismissal in Melbourne
What's the story
The dismissal of Indian cricketer Yashasvi Jaiswal during the Boxing Day Test against Australia has sparked a debate. Former England skipper Michael Vaughan and ex-Australian player Mark Waugh have dismissed the controversy, asserting that Jaiswal was indeed out. This stance contradicts the views expressed by BCCI Vice President Rajeev Shukla and Indian cricket team captain Rohit Sharma post-match.
Details
Jaiswal's dismissal: A closer look at the incident
The incident happened when Jaiswal, who was batting on 84, tried to hook a bouncer bowled by Cummins. Wicketkeeper Alex Carey successfully collected the ball as the Australians appealed for caught-behind. On-field umpire Joel Wilson initially ruled it not-out, prompting Australia to review his decision. Real-time Snicko showed a flat line as the ball crossed the bat, wheareas regular replays showed a big deflection.
Decision
Third umpire's decision and its impact on the match
Third umpire Sharfuddoula overturned the on-field decision on the basis of the deflection seen in regular replays, ruling in Australia's favor. After his dismissal, Jaiswal was seen speaking having a word with the umpires before eventually walking off the field. The dismissal left India reeling at 140/7 in their chase of 340. They finally lost by 184 runs.
Controversy response
Vaughan urges end to controversy over Jaiswal's dismissal
Vaughan has called for an end to the incessant debate over Jaiswal's dismissal. On X (formerly Twitter), he wrote, "Seriously .. all this has to stop .. It was OUT .. all decisions yesterday were the correct ones .. Australia were just better this week." This directly counters Shukla's criticism of the third umpire's decision and Sharma's remarks on technology not being 100% accurate.
Twitter Post
Here is Vaughan's post!
Seriously .. all this has to stop .. It was OUT .. all decisions yesterday were the correct ones .. Australia were just better this week .. #Fact https://t.co/VGKfRkIB8j
— Michael Vaughan (@MichaelVaughan) December 30, 2024
Agreement
Waugh supports Vaughan's stance on Jaiswal's dismissal
Waugh has also echoed his sentiments with Vaughan, saying there should be no doubt about Jaiswal's dismissal. He wrote on X, "Let's get this straight once and for all. Jaiswal was clearly out it was a very obvious deflection off the bat/glove. Not sure how umpire missed it in the first place." This further dismisses Shukla's criticism of the third umpire and Sharma's post-match comments.
Twitter Post
A look at Waugh's comments
Let’s get this straight once and for all. Jaiswal was clearly out it was a very obvious deflection off the bat/glove. Not sure how umpire missed it in the first place. Snicko missed it maybe as it was a very soft glancing blow but at the end of the day right decision was made.
— Mark Waugh (@juniorwaugh349) December 30, 2024
Dismissal debate
Taylor dismisses controversy surrounding Jaiswal's dismissal
Former Australian skipper Mark Taylor has also dismissed the controversy surrounding Jaiswal's dismissal. He said, "To me, there is no controversy. You can see from that replay that he clearly edges the ball, and there is a clear deviation." This statement supports Vaughan and Waugh's stance on the issue and contradicts Shukla and Sharma's post-match comments.